Skip to main content

Myth-Busting: The Illusion of Control

Family portrait by six-year-old Sammy. Note that I take center stage in a larger-than-life role.

Mothers are biologically hard-wired to ensure the survival of the species. They are charged with preparing their offspring to leave the nest by teaching them the skills they’ll need to navigate the world independently.     

With reality television shows and women's magazines glorifying the exploits of pushy and meddlesome moms, controlling moms who demand that their children live up to unreasonably high standards, one gets the sense that modern mothers grade themselves on their children’s achievements.

From the women who trundle their pre-schoolers from one resume-building activity to another, to those who spend the equivalent of college tuition on their kids’ elite sports leagues and dance teams, many moms seem to believe that it is their level of devotion that determines their child’s destiny.

There was a brief spell, very early on in my parenting life, where I could have bought into that fantasy. Unfortunately, I bumped into breast cancer, which swiftly rid me of the notion that I could plot my daughter’s future success. I couldn’t even control the health of my body. How would it be possible for me to control Sammy’s ascent to adulthood?  

That doesn’t mean that I didn’t invest in the requisite activities. I signed her up at a popular gymnastics club, took her to their tumbling and dance classes, and laughed off their suggestion that my five-year-old demonstrated a real talent for pom dance. Neither of her parents possessed a penchant for rhythmic movement, so I could only surmise that the suggestion was a red herring meant to lure us into the added expense of joining the competition team.

If I had any other wistful desires to mold my child into a prodigy of some form, they disappeared when, midway through my second pregnancy, a fatal anomaly was revealed in my unborn baby's genetic blueprint. I tumbled down the rabbit hole of realization that any control I thought I had over my children's future was a figment of wishful thinking.

It was a random error, a chromosomal defect. Such defects do not discriminate. It could have happened to anyone. I only knew that it had happened to me.

Uncertainty was the only constant I had to work with. I planned for the inevitable and hoped for the impossible, suspended in the limbo of not knowing. I savored every kick and cursed every contraction.

I wrote a birth plan that doubled as a living will. In the unlikely event of live birth, there would be no resuscitation or medical intervention. I wanted my baby to experience only peace.

I planned activities to entertain seven-year-old Sammy and watched, helpless, as she crumbled under the weight of our circumstances. Her tantrums were legendary and public.

She directed the bulk of her fury at me because I was the one growing the baby. I became her punching bag. It took every last ounce of my self-control not to hit her back.

I couldn’t keep up with the demands of work and home and frankly, I stopped trying. I didn’t care if the house was clean or the laundry done. I was keeping my family afloat, and that was enough.

My baby turned happy somersaults in my belly, seemingly unaware of her family's descent into chaos. I rubbed my swollen belly and wished that I could stay pregnant forever.

Five weeks before her due date, my little girl burst into the world. Cradled against my chest, she slipped away two hours later. When I left the hospital, my arms were empty. My heart was full.

The pit of loss swallowed me whole. I mourned the daughter I'd buried and ached with her big sister’s pain. I blamed myself, not only for my baby’s death, but for the disintegration of Sammy’s previously sheltered life.

She took my hand at the funeral and wouldn’t let go. Day after day, she pulled me through, dragging me back to life.

I know that I failed her, more times than I could ever begin to count. I was too sad to play, too weary to read to her, too broken to fully attend to her needs.

I also know that I showed her how to muster courage and move forward in the face of insurmountable challenge. She gets her personality from her father. She gets her perseverance from me.

I still grapple with grief and guilt, worry about the emotional scars she carries. I comfort myself with the knowledge that I did the best I could, under the circumstances.


I hope that when Sammy’s an adult, she’ll forgive me. I know that when she’s a mom, she’ll understand.

Popular posts from this blog

The Tortures of Tamoxifen, Part 2

Though my oncologist was not thrilled with me quitting tamoxifen, she did give me her blessing. “Take a break and see how you feel. Just promise me that you’ll consider starting up again.” I stopped taking the pills and within a few weeks noticed an improvement in my energy level. My hot flashes were less frequent, weight management a bit easier. Running, my favorite leisure activity, stopped feeling like a chore. I couldn’t quite ratchet my pace back up to pre-cancer levels, but I could finally hold my own with my running buddies again. I harbored a small hope that stopping the medicine would put me back into my previous ovaries-still-in-action hormonal state of being. Sadly, aside from one scant period right after I abandoned the drug, my body stayed stubbornly stuck in menopause. My symptoms weren’t nearly as bad as they’d been on tamoxifen, but they were still there, mocking me. I started to have doubts about my decision. The drumbeat of, “What if?” reverberated in my ...

My Love-Hate Relationship with Teaching

I have a confession to make, one that seemingly meets the criteria of a mundane mid-life crisis: I love what I do, but I hate my job. I’m a kindergarten teacher by trade. I adore children—always have, always will—and have a natural affinity for the littlest learners. I enjoy watching their growth across a school year, the way they come in green and fresh as newly planted seeds at the start, and leave my classroom as saplings stretching toward the infinite sky of knowledge and understanding. I hate the metrics that are used to define my students’ performance (and my own). I loathe the over-reliance on a narrow band of assessment measures that ignores the intangibles of student growth and extinguishes the joy of learning. I resent seeing children reduced to numbers on a grid in the name of data-based decision-making. I cherish the time I spend with my students in the Zone of Proximal Development. I thrive on the everyday teachable moments that enable me to coach into my stud...

Blaming the Victim

“Everything happens for a reason.” It’s one of the most common rote responses we have when we hear of someone else’s tragedy. I’ve been on the receiving end of this comment more times than I care to count…and I hate it. Seriously, I’d love to see it eradicated from the English language. When people tell me that there’s a reason I got cancer, it implies that there’s a reason why they didn’t. When they tell me that there’s a reason I lost my baby, the unspoken message is—well, you know. Those words, strung together in an overture of sympathy, provide comfort only to the person speaking them. They represent a very convenient and human reaction to tragedy—seeking meaning in a way that enables us to distance ourselves from the possibility that such a thing could happen to us. Interestingly, I’ve never heard this phrase uttered by a parent who’s buried a child, or a widow who lost her beloved spouse. I’ve never heard someone with a life-threatening medical condition suggest ...